What to Do if You Think Someone Is Unfit to Drive
You can raise the concern with the driver, their doctor, or the DMV, and the DMV is the only one who can actually require a retest.
Free to compare
Start with the DMV in the state where they're licensed
Every state has a process for reporting a driver who may be unsafe, though the name of the form and the office that handles it varies. Some states let anyone file a report. Others only accept them from doctors, law enforcement, or family members. The DMV can require a vision test, a written test, a road test, or a medical evaluation depending on what the report describes.
This works because the DMV, not a family member or a doctor, holds the authority to suspend or restrict a license. A conversation with the driver might help, and a doctor's input carries weight, but neither one can take the keys away. If you want something to actually happen, the DMV is where the decision gets made.
What you say matters more than who you are
A vague complaint doesn't give the DMV much to act on. Specific, recent examples do: a crash, a near miss, getting lost on a familiar route, confusion at intersections, trouble reading signs. Write down what you've seen and when, before you file anything.
Some states ask for a report from the driver's doctor instead of, or in addition to, one from family. If the driver has a condition that affects memory, vision, or reaction time, their doctor may already be required to report it under that state's rules. Ask the doctor directly whether that applies.
The DMV will usually keep the identity of the person who filed the report confidential, but policies differ by state. If you're worried about the driver knowing it was you, ask the DMV how they handle that before you submit anything in writing.
What families get wrong before they file
Taking away the car keys or hiding them doesn't end the legal ability to drive. Only the DMV can suspend, restrict, or revoke a license. A driver without keys can still get a replacement car or borrow one.
A family member can't retest a driver informally and expect the state to honor it. If you want the state to require a retest, that request has to go through the DMV's actual process, not a private agreement within the family.
Waiting for one big incident before saying anything is common, but smaller warning signs tend to repeat and get worse. If you've already noticed a pattern, it's worth starting the conversation, or the paperwork, before something happens rather than after.
Questions people ask about this
Can a doctor report an unsafe driver to the DMV?
In some states, yes, and in a few states doctors are required to report certain conditions. Rules differ on whether this is mandatory, voluntary, or protected from liability, so ask the driver's doctor what their state requires of them.
Will the DMV tell the driver who reported them?
Many states keep the reporter's identity confidential, but this isn't universal. Call the DMV in the driver's state and ask directly how they handle reporter confidentiality before you file.
What happens after you report a driver to the DMV?
The DMV typically reviews the report and decides whether to require a vision test, written test, road test, or medical evaluation. The outcome depends on what the report describes and what the state's process allows.
Can you lose your license just from a family member's complaint?
A complaint alone usually doesn't end a license. It typically triggers a review or a required test, and the result of that test or evaluation is what determines whether the license is restricted or taken away.
Does an unsafe driving report affect car insurance?
A report to the DMV by itself isn't something insurers see. What affects a policy is the outcome, such as a license restriction, a suspension, or a new accident or violation on the record.
If a license ends up restricted or a driver needs a different kind of policy, it helps to see how that changes the options.
Write down specific examples of what you've seen, including dates, rather than a general impression. Call the DMV in the state where the driver is licensed and ask what their reporting process requires and whether it accepts reports from family. If the driver has a medical condition that might be relevant, ask their doctor whether state law requires them to report it separately. Ask the DMV how they handle confidentiality if you're concerned about the driver finding out who filed the report. Keep a copy of whatever you submit and ask what happens next, including how long a review typically takes in that state.
